Avoiding
Probate
By
Michael J. Mc Guire, Attorney at Law
This article is
designed to give the reader a little understanding about
what the probate process is and is not and why it is
preferable to avoid it if possible. The first thing you
should know is the two
purposes of probate:
1)
to pay-off the just
debts of the decedent (deceased person); and,
2)
to distribute what is left of the decedent's estate to
either: a)
those people, and in those amounts, as are named in the
decedent's will, or, if the decedent did not leave a
will, then b)
the probate court will determine who are the rightful
heirs of the decedent.
Having
a Will Does Not Avoid Probate
So, the first thing we
have learned is that writing a will is not a means of
avoiding probate; it is simply a legal way of informing
the probate court of your intentions for your estate
after you are no longer around to give instructions.
Sometimes a probate court will determine that your
instructions cannot be followed. Usually this will be
because some of your survivors are fighting over the
appropriateness of the distribution you had planned. We
cannot in an article of this nature discuss all of the
possible situations which might arise. What you should
know is that the court has the ultimate power to make
determinations, considering your wishes, the law of your
state, and the arguments of the lawyers who represent the
greedy group of relatives you've left behind.
If you would prefer to
rest in peace, you should consider a
Living
Trust. A
Living
Will is something
different, which we will discuss below. A living trust is
a document by which you declare that your assets will be
distributed according to a plan you determine and without
any necessity of a court's intervention. You are creating
something like a holding company for your assets. You may
declare that while you are alive you and your spouse are
in control of all of your assets, exactly as you now are.
Upon your passsing, or your spouse's, the survivor is
completely in control. You also name some successors who
will be in control upon the passing of both you and your
spouse. You will direct that upon the passing of both
spouses, this named successor (or successors) will
distribute your property according to plans you have
written down.
The successor trustee, as
he/she is called, has full power to simply sell all of
your assets and distribute the proceeds as you have
instructed--virtually any distribution plan is possible
with very few exceptions which your attorney will avoid.
Now, either a will or a trust instrument can be
challenged in court after your demise. However, trusts
are generally not challenged because the assets will
almost always be distributed before anyone thinks to
challenge the matter; whereas, during the probate of a
will, all the assets are tied-up in court making
challenges more likely. Compare
the probate process and the living trust process
described below.
The
Probate Process
If you write a will
properly and leave it where someone knows about it, the
executor named by you to execute, or carry-out, the terms
of your will must apply to the Superior Court to have the
will approved and its terms fulfilled per your
instructions. Generally, your executor will need to hire
an attorney to help complete the entire process. It is
very difficult to figure-out what needs to be done
without the services of an attorney. Most states,
California included, will set a standard percentage of
your estate as the attorney's fees for this. If there is
any real estate to sell, there will be extra fees to pay.
If there are any complications or court battles beyond
the common ones, there will be extra fees to pay. These
are referred to as extraordinary fees (and boy can they
be!) and they will be paid in addition to the standard
fees. The executor will be entitled to receive a similar
amount as fees for his/her services during the probate
process. All of these fees will be taken out of your
assets before any distributions are made.
The paperwork filed
informs the court that you have passed away and that you
have left a will and that you have named the executor to
serve in that capacity and asks the court to approve of
the starting of the process. The paperwork in California
is called a "Petition."
The executor will
place ads (the attorney takes care of this usually) in
the paper announcing to the world, and in particular,
interested parties to whom you might owe money, that you
are gone and that unless they step forward and prove that
you owed them money, all your assets will also soon be
gone.
The executor's job is to
find all of your assets and determine what debts you have
remaining (from facts they are able to gather, and from
any claims made against the estate). Once your assets are
gathered and your debts (including any taxes owed) are
paid, and the statutorily required time period elapses
(six months in California) your executor will ask the
court to approve the final distribution of your remaining
estate.
This process takes no
less than six months, generally it is not completed
before nine months, and although the court has a goal
that it should not take more than one year, it often
does. Note that at anytime during the process, anyone can
make a claim against the estate or object to the
appointment of the executor you've chosen, or object to
the actions of the executor or object to the distribution
plan. Not one dime will be distributed until the court
approves it, the entire process is a matter of public
record for anyone to review, so anyone who thinks they
might have a right to some of your assets has everything
to gain, and nothing to lose, by filing their claim or
objection with the court and taking their
shot.
The
Living Trust
Unlike a
probate, a trust can remain completely private if you so
instruct your attorney and your successor
trustee. Right now,
you're in charge of everything you own. If you want your
money, you walk into the bank, sign a withdrawal slip and
they hand you the money--because your signature is on the
signature card. If you were gone tomorrow, no-one has
access to that money because you left no instructions. If
you left a will, the probate court will give your
executor the power to get that money, but only after the
long probate process. You could, of course, put someone
else's name (your child, for example) on the account, but
then the money is half theirs. Perhaps you trust them not
to spend it while you're alive, but what if they are sued
for something and a judgment is entered against them?
Then the judgment creditor will be able to execute his
judgment against your account.
The best situation is to
have all of your assets held in the name of the trust. It
is often called a Living Trust, because while you're
alive you are the person in charge of it and all of its
assets--just as you are today. Then when you die, the
trust lives on. The person you have named as successor
trustee simply follows the directions you have left and
distributes your assets as you have directed. No muss, no
fuss, no executor fees. By the time someone comes along
to fight over the money, it's been distributed. Now
understand, your debts must still be paid, including
applicable taxes. There are ways to reduce the tax burden
in certain circumstances. Any trust and probate lawyer in
your area will be aware of these particulars.
A
Living Will
This is
completely separate from either a will or a living trust.
It is usually
contemplated, however, at the same time that you are
drafting any of your estate planning documents. It is an
instrument by which you inform your family and your
medical providers about how you would like to be treated
in the event of a catastrophic illness or accident, or
during the last days of your life. For example, you might
not want to be kept on life-support systems if the
doctors have determined that there is no hope for
survival without the machines. Since you are not able to
speak for yourself at that time, the doctors are not able
to disconnect the machines unless you have given the
power to make that decision to someone else.
In California we have a
"Power
of Attorney for Health Care."
Many states have
drafted a similar, legally approved document for this
purpose. In this document you can set forth specific
medical procedures you would approve of and which you
would not, or you can simply state that your "health care
agent", the person named by you, has the power to make
those decisions for you. I recommend these documents to
all of my clients and I recommend that after you sign it
you discuss it with your family and your doctors so that
everyone knows you feelings and your wishes and what
you've done about it.
These so-called living
wills have gained in popularity and now are being used
for more than just health care instructions. They are
seen as a very good vehicle to inform your loved ones of
your thoughts and wishes in your final days. You may have
heard about a document called the "Five Wishes Living
Will." This is a very informative document, but it is not
legally enforceable in California. Please see the
accompanying article entitled "Living Wills" for a more
detailed discussion of these versatile and important
instruments.